Home » Home Improvement » How to Find a Good Contractor (7-Step Vetting)
How to Find a Good Contractor (7-Step Vetting)

The process
Define scope in writing, collect 3+ bids, verify license and insurance, call 3 references from the last year, check court records for liens, sign a fixed-price contract with milestones, hold 10% retention. Skip any step and you become the cautionary tale.
Worked example: $15,000 bath remodel bids
Bid A $11,000 (no license number, 50% deposit), Bid B $15,500 (licensed, itemized, 10% deposit, 10% retention), Bid C $19,000 (design-build, warranty). Bid B wins: the $4,000 gap to A is insurance, warranty, and permits. Cheapest bids omit exactly what protects you.
Red flags
- Demands over 10–15% deposit or cash only
- No physical address, license number, or insurance certificate
- Door-knocking after storms with today-only pricing
- Vague allowances instead of fixed specifications
- Refuses permits to save you money
Contract must-haves
Start and end dates with delay penalties, payment tied to milestones (never time-based draws), exact brands and model numbers, change-order pricing method, warranty terms in writing, and cleanup responsibility. Verbal promises are worth the paper they are printed on.
FAQ
- Where to search? State license board first, then referrals, then review sites — in that order.
- How many bids? Three minimum; five for jobs over $20,000.
- Pay in full early for discount? Never — discounts under 5% are not worth losing all leverage.
Cost reality
Vetting costs nothing but an afternoon of calls. Hiring wrong costs 2× the job to fix plus months of stress. Licensed, insured, itemized, retained — four words worth thousands.
Limits
Even perfect vetting cannot prevent every dispute — document everything in writing and photograph daily progress. For jobs over $50,000 consider a construction attorney review ($300–$500). See our repair estimators for planning ranges.
Reference calls that work
Ask references: did they start and finish on schedule, how did they handle surprises, would you hire them again, and may I see the work. Drive by two past jobs — curb views reveal finishing quality instantly. Skip references older than 2 years; crews and standards change.
Payment structure
Standard safe schedule: 10% at signing, 25% at demolition complete, 25% rough-in passed, 25% cabinets and finishes set, 10% retention at punch-list completion plus 10% final on walkthrough approval. Never let payments run ahead of visible progress.
One last rule
Everything verbal gets confirmed by text or email the same day. Nice contractors with bad paperwork still produce bad outcomes — the contract protects you both, and professionals respect clients who document.
Related tools: Roof | Plumbing | HVAC | All tools
Why vetting matters more than price
The cheapest quote is rarely the cheapest job. Poor work costs twice: once to do it, and again to put it right. A structured vetting process filters out the risk before you hand over money, and it protects you if something goes wrong.
The seven-step check
- Verify licensing and insurance. Ask for the licence number and a certificate of insurance; call to confirm.
- Check the address and identity. A real business has a verifiable address and a landline or established presence.
- Read recent reviews. Look for patterns, not one-off complaints, and prefer detailed reviews over star ratings alone.
- Ask for local references. Then actually call them and ask how the job ended, not just how it started.
- Get three written quotes. Compare scope, not just totals; a suspiciously low bid usually excludes something.
- Insist on a written contract. Scope, price, timeline, payment stages, permits and warranty all in writing.
- Never pay in full upfront. Tie payments to milestones and hold back a final amount until you are satisfied.
Red flags to walk away from
- Pressure to sign today or a “discount that expires”.
- Cash-only demands and no written contract.
- Large upfront deposit requests.
- No licence number, insurance or verifiable address.
- Vague answers about who will actually do the work.
FAQ
Should I choose the lowest quote? No — choose the clearest, best-reviewed quote whose scope matches what you need.
How much deposit is fair? A modest materials deposit, with the rest tied to progress.
What if work is poor? A written contract and milestone payments give you leverage to get it fixed before final payment.
Related reading: roof repair costs and plumber cost ranges.